AAFA_logo copy.jpg

Business groups file amicus brief, say USTR tariffs process ‘flawed’

Posted August 11, 2021

 

WASHINGTON, D.C. – The American Apparel & Footwear Association (AAFA), the Retail Litigation Center, the National Retail Federation, the Consumer Technology Association, the Footwear Distributors and Retailers of America, the Juvenile Products Manufacturers Association and the Toy Association this week filed a “friend of the court” amicus brief in the U.S. Court of International Trade.

 

The trade groups submitted the brief in support of businesses and their workers that have been negatively impacted by a series of escalating tariffs covering virtually all Chinese imports to the United States imposed by the United States Trade Representative (USTR).

 

In 2018, following a Section 301 investigation into China’s trade practices regarding forced technology transfer and intellectual property rights protection, the Trump Administration initiated several massive tariffs against Chinese imports. Thousands of American businesses have been forced to pay these taxes to import Chinese goods and products, which ultimately result in higher prices for U.S. consumers. The Biden Administration has kept these tariffs in place when American businesses are doing their best to safely serve customers, and keep workers on their payrolls, during the pandemic. 

 

In September 2020, more than 6,000 plaintiffs filed lawsuits challenging the List 3 and List 4A tariffs as unlawful under Section 301 of the Trade Act of 1974 arguing that the USTR exceeded its authority when it imposed tariffs without attempting to connect them to any underlying investigation of China’s trade practices. The amicus brief supports the plaintiffs’ arguments and highlights USTR’s violation of its statutory obligations under the Administrative Procedure Act by failing to give adequate opportunity for, or consideration of, public comments.

 

The staggering scale and far-reaching effects of the proposed tariffs required USTR to take a thoughtful approach consistent with its statutory obligation under the Administrative Procedure Act. Instead, USTR imposed compressed public-comment timelines, which often gave businesses only a few days to analyze the impacts on supply chains and retail operations and develop thoughtful comments. To make matters worse, despite receiving nearly 10,000 comments and pieces of testimony, the overwhelming majority of which opposed the tariffs, USTR refused to respond to any of the identified concerns.  
 
According to the amicus brief:

 

“Those proposed tariffs implicated hundreds of billions of dollars of imports and impacted almost every facet of the U.S. economy. Many stakeholders, including amici’s members must plan out their international supply chains and delivery schedules months in advance. Not surprisingly, these businesses needed time to review the hundreds of thousands of products they sell to evaluate the availability and feasibility of alternative non-Chinese sources and to assess impacts on supply chains and retail operations.
 

“If USTR had satisfied its obligation to allow for meaningful comments from amici and others and had actually considered them, it would have recognized the considerable harm its actions would inflict. The tariffs are a hidden tax on U.S. consumers, hurting domestic producers, retailers, and customers alike. And, as predicted, they have had a significant adverse impact on the U.S. economy.”
 

The amicus brief was written by Joseph R. Palmore and Adam L. Sorensen of Morrison & Foerster LLP. View the amicus brief in its entirety here.

 

Source: AAFA

  • LinkedIn
  • Wix Facebook page
  • Instagram
  • Wix Twitter page
Zimmer_ad_inside_920X496.jpg
Banner_WeavingTechnical_ETC_230x124.gif
Navis-TubeTex-Web-Inside-Page-090518_opt
SSM_eTextileCommunication_Banner_230x124
STA_ad_011520-optimized_compressed.gif
ATMA_Techtextil 2021 ad_website_011121-O
Lang_Ligon_eTC_inside_pages_ad_2021-comp
AB Carter-website ad_051021_DRAFT1.gif
Murata_eTC_Ad_111619_FINAL.gif
Frankl-Thomas-sidebar-ad-080117_256_opti
PAF Sales-BTSR eTC Website ad_093020-Opt
Mezger-sidebar-ad-230X124-062816-Draft2_
ETC_banner_4_REAL_MoreRES_compressed.jpg